All Swimming Pools will be subject to stains from a variety of sources – vegetation, insects, pool chemicals, sun-tanning and barrier creams, and oils, cosmetic preparations, air-borne pollutants and the myriad other things that can be tipped, dropped or blown into a swimming pool.
Provided they are cleaned promptly there is little lasting damage.
Liners manufactured from plasticised PVC are no different and can be permanently stained if not cleaned regularly and correctly.
This page sets out a number of common staining problems and explains their causes and treatments.
Alkorplan Printed and Reinforced Liner Membranes are coated with an acrylic lacquer which, in addition to protecting the print and reducing degradation from plasticiser loss and UV penetration, also gives excellent stain resistance.
In most cases, staining of the water line is a combination of :
In the UK, the dominant wind direction is from the southwest. Atmospheric pollution will be deposited on the northeast walls.
These are also the walls that receive the highest quantity of solar energy.
These will typically be the sides where staining of the water line will be the worst, as the effects reinforce each another. Of course, the presence of buildings and trees will also have an influence.
Regular cleaning of the water line is the best way to prevent early degradation of the waterproofing membrane.
Lacquered membranes have higher resistance to this kind of degradation and are easier to clean.
Proprietary products specifically designed for cleaning PVC liners should be used to remove staining. Under no circumstances should solvents or abrasives be used on Alkorplan liners as they will remove the protective lacquer and any print.
During the swimming pool season of 2006, swimming pool membrane manufacturers became aware that yellow staining of the water line had become an increasing problem.
These stains did not correspond in any way with the usual pollution of the water line, which is generally grey/black/brown in colour, and which is not too difficult to remove if cleaning is carried out on a regular basis.
Grey staining is generally found on the downwind side of the pool.
The yellow stains have a very distinctive colour; they appear in less than two days and they are very difficult to clean. Several pool owners have stated that the stains appeared after people using sun cream had made use of the pool.
RENOLIT laboratory tests have shown that the most probable cause of the staining is a reaction between sun cream and copper.
Lacquered membranes are less easily stained than unlacquered products, but there is still a possibility of some staining
The yellow stains dissolve in highly chlorinated water. So, theoretically it is possible to remove the stains by raising the water level above the stains and shock chlorinating the swimming pool water. In practice the stains dissolve rather slowly, so it can take several weeks before the stains have disappeared, and the high chlorine level could also attack the swimming pool membrane.
The yellow stains also dissolve in strong solvents, such as ethyl acetate. This solvent can only be used to remove the yellow staining on plain unlacquered liners. Ethyl acetate cannot be used on printed products as this solvent will remove the lacquer and print.
A better method is to avoid staining by not using copper-based water treatment products. This is also the suggestion of the French standard NF T 54-804T1 : Plastics — Plasticised polyvinyl chloride) (PVC-P) reinforced membranes for inground swimming pools — Guidance for the installation, repair, use and maintenance) :
ATTENTION – The use of copper sulfate is prohibited.
This standard has been endorsed by the major manufacturers of swimming pool membranes (RENOLIT, DLW, Sika,..) and several distributors and installers.
Nowadays, in many European countries, copper sulphate is rarely used. As an algicide, it has been replaced by quaternary ammonium compounds, which have the added advantage of not colouring the swimmer’s hair.
In France, the major manufacturers of swimming pool chemicals offer products without copper sulphate specially for liner pools. See : http://www.bayrol.com/en/swimming-pool-water-care-tips/pool-cleaning-care/index.html http://www.archwaterproducts.eu/contenu_hth.php?id_famille=91Liner pools have no rough surfaces, such as the grouted joints in ceramic pools, therefore a liner pool does not really need an algicide : it is perfectly possible to maintain good water quality with only the use of chlorine tablets.
The presence of bacteria behind swimming pool membranes can lead to the staining of liner membranes.
In almost all cases this is due to bacteria producing “hydrogen sulphide” a colourless gas which migrates through the membrane and then reacts with dissolved metals (such as copper) in the swimming pool water.
While PVC is an excellent water barrier it is a poor gas barrier.
At first sight the solution seems simple : avoid the presence of bacteria behind the membrane or avoid the presence of metals in the swimming pool water; in both cases this would eliminate the formation of metal sulphides. In practice however, it is quite difficult to remove completely all bacterial activity behind the membrane. Nor is it possible to avoid the presence of a low quantity of metals salts in the swimming pool water.
Experience tells us that it is better to keep both parameters on an acceptable level: there will be few problems with stains if the membrane is installed on a clean structure (old structures should be cleaned and disinfected before installation of a membrane) and if the metal level in the swimming pool is kept reasonably low.
Metal salts such as copper sulphate should not be used as a swimming pool water treatment product.
Fortunately, these black copper stains dissolve in chlorinated water. However, as long as there are bacteria behind the liner producing hydrogen sulphide and as long as there is copper in the swimming pool water, the stains will continue to form.